All I can say is if it happens to her it could happen to any of us. Orthomom…Please feel free to use this blog and this blogger to help. You have my e-mail. Have a good Shabbos, and don’t worry—– this too shall pass.
Orthomom Gets Sued
I received the following by e-mail, I do not see it online, nor does it come up on any internet searches. However, I assume it actually appeared in the newspaper in question. Here goes:
FLOGGED ON BLOG, SHE’S SEEKING ID
A LAWRENCE school board member fed up with anonymous kvetching about her on a blog is going to court to stop it from calling her a bigot and an anti-Semite.
Pamela Greenbaum, who serves on the Nassau town’s board of education, filed papers against Google over nasty comments posted about her on the Orthomom blog.
In the papers filed Tuesday in Manhattan Supreme Court, Greenbaum said she was “horrified” to discover that she had been labeled a bigot on the Google-owned blog after voting against using public funds for what she called “private school interests.”
“I was even more horrified when I discovered the blog reported over 300,000 visitors,” Greenbaum said in court papers.
Greenbaum alleges that Orthomom – which focuses on issues of interest to Long Island’s Orthodox Jewish communities – slandered her by calling her ugly and an anti-Semite.
Greenbaum, who is Jewish but not Orthodox, seeks to unmask the blogger known only as Orthomom.
“Every day that the defamatory material remains on the Internet for all to see, I continue to be harmed as more such material is posted,”she said in court papers.
A few points:
Pamela Greenbaum is simply not telling the truth here. I never said any such thing about her. She says that I “slandered her by calling her a bigot and an anti-semite”. Lie. She might be referring to something that a commenter on my site said. She should say so.
Pamela Greenbaum also says she that she “continue[s] to be harmed” “every day that the defamatory material remains on the internet for all to see”. Hm. if that were really true, do you think that perhaps Mrs. Greenbaum would have contacted me to ask me to remove the comments that bothered her so much? I have been asked in the past to remove comments and I have always done so when warranted. I have no idea which the comments in question are – my blog has gotten many thousands of comments on this matter, and Pamela Greenbaum hasn’t ever contacted me. Which, of course, leads me to believe this is more about “unmasking” me than about her hurt feelings. I mean, come on. Does anyone on her legal advisory board even follow the relevant law to this frivolous lawsuit?
Well, I will say this: Good luck. I have it on expert legal opinion that this case is a joke.
Update: Krum links with a great post that points out that aside from the fact that the statements were made by commenters and not by me, calling someone “bigoted” is not, by legal definition, defamatory.
Update: DovBear’s show of support.
Update: Chaim is on my side.
Update: JPT comes out hibernation to weigh in.